Scenario planning – a quick introduction

I have yet to find the prophetic marketer who factored a global pandemic into their 2020 brand plan. And yet here we are, all having to deal with it – and the potentially protracted aftermath. If we can take anything from it, perhaps one provocation is to take a fresh look at how we plan.
Scenario planning (SP) has been used by a some companies for very many years now, although its popularity has grown in the last decade or so. This has coincided with the recognition of the increasingly fluid landscape businesses face (often referred to a “VUCA” world – volatile, uncertain, complex & ambiguous).
The point of SP is not to forecast the future precisely, but to work up a handful of different and plausible futures, then explore the impact on your brand or business, before figuring out the implications for strategy.
False comfort
Even the most ardent scenario planners may not have had today’s scenario exactly mapped out! But the process of thinking about different futures – rather than taking false comfort from extrapolating a straight-line forecast – inevitably makes a brand better prepared to deal with a range of eventualities.
Another of the many benefits of a SP approach is that it requires leaders to bring in alternative perspectives and consider more than one future landscape.
Many strategic plans take one version of the future and then may apply a pessimistic, realistic and optimistic lens to project different levels of outcome. Naturally, the pessimistic view is then relayed to head office whilst staff bonuses are pegged to the optimistic!
In some organisations, planning becomes more about socialising and then coalescing around one agreed version of the future. Alternative views are unhelpful and unwelcome.
SP relies on having more than one (perhaps 2 – 5) different scenarios, each being created to tell a different story about how the external world could develop.
Incredibly practical
On the face of it, dreaming up different versions of the future might seem conceptual and passive. But scenario planning can be incredibly practical – not least the team is more thoroughly prepared for whatever context evolves.

Depending on the scope, the process of scenario planning can take 3-4 weeks or several months and it’s based on a number of important steps –

  • Agreeing the focal question (what we need SP to help us with)
  • Identifying driving forces (including identifying the most relevant trends & uncertainties in relation to our focal question)
  • Developing scenario frameworks (how the driving forces might combine to create different futures (ideally ones that challenge today’s conventional wisdom)
  • Building stories to explain how the scenarios could unfold (stories help engage people and help people understand why and how the scenarios are plausible)
  • Reviewing risks, implications, and strategic options (essentially, asking what each scenario means for us & what are we going to do about it)

The process will typically include a good deal of offline desk research & interviews, plus at least two workshops with senior stakeholders. Normally, workshops are used to firstly review/agree the scenarios and second, to review the strategy in light of those scenarios.

Shell is widely credited with pioneering the SP approach, for example using it to understand fundamental questions about the long-term demand for fossil fuels, or alternative energy. They even routinely publish scenarios online as a form of thought leadership.
Re-sizing the process
Whilst a 40-year commitment to scenario planning demonstrates its value for this multibillion-dollar oil giant, the principles can also be scaled to work at almost any level of planning – business unit, category or brand.
Scenario Planning is especially useful right now. By adding structure, the approach can help businesses rapidly explore and prepare for a post-lockdown world, at a time when it’s still highly uncertain how things will pan out.
Sometimes when we are challenged, we are more creative. Scenario planning lacks the (false) comfort of a straight-line forecast. However, there is something quite honest about recognising that we do not – and cannot – exactly know how things will develop. But by applying SP principles it is possible to feel more confident in our ability to deal with whatever is thrown at us.
If you’d like help planning for the immediate or longer-term future, one of the ways we can assist is with facilitation. This type of support organise the team’s thinking around a framework. Critically, it also frees up time for senior leaders to actively participate and influence direction, without having to worry about managing a process as well.

Latest insights

Resource: Energy Inventory

Resource: Energy Inventory

Energy Inventory self-score questionnaire - a free-to-download resource. Click to open: ENERGY INVENTORY DEC26

Quotes about discernment

Quotes about discernment

"Avoid the superficial, penetrate the complex, go to the heart of the problem, and pinpoint the key factors” Bruce Lee   “A 'no' uttered from...

In a world of noise, complexity, and competing agendas, the leaders who win are those who cut through — simplifying smartly, then acting with clarity and conviction.

If that’s what you’re aiming for, let’s talk. No pitch, just a genuine conversation with someone who’s been in your shoes.