Whether it’s a periodic update to strategy or urgent response to a competitor move, reading a situation well is key to creating and landing the right plan.
But it can be tough to discern the signal from the noise. It’s also difficult if – even with good intent – our team prefers giving us good news over bad.
But there is a deceptively simple question I’ve found useful –
What is the market telling us?
This helps shift attention from internal to external-facing thinking. It encourages objectivity and helps distance the messenger from the message (especially if that message is unpalatable).
Recently this question successfully helped unlock progress with a client whose large premium brand was running instore promotions but having less sales impact each year (while also costing more to run).
The client’s context was one of multi-year raw material cost inflation which it recovered through price increases to customers. However, competition increased prices at a slower rate and, slowly over time, a substantial gap in pricing appeared in the market.
By focusing on the brand’s revenues, you would not be especially alarmed. In fact the year on year growth was flattering, it just looked like a promotional problem.
Overall the market was is decent health – certainly not losing buyers as were were – so it was definitely an “us” problem.
What was the market telling us?
After some analysis, the market was clearly saying that although shoppers loved the brand and were prepared to pay a premium for us, as the gap got bigger, a growing number thought we we were just too expensive, so switched elsewhere.
We concluded that in practice our promotional support was becoming less and less about attracting buyers (as intended) and more about subsiding a too-high base price. The answer would lie in improving value perception – reducing the pricing gap, increasing perceptions of brand benefits, or perhaps a combination of the two.
In this example, asking the question ‘what is the market telling us’ enabled us to reframe the issue from one of internal financials to the underlying consumer issue we needed to fix.





