The hidden cost of dishonesty (and why leaders must fix it before anything else)

Every now and then, a situation comes along that perfectly illustrates a universal truth.

A while ago, I got to experience an example (of several I’ve seen over the years) of where a business was tying itself in knots because nobody was telling the truth.

On paper, the sales forecast looked positive. Confidence all round. Big numbers. Strong pipeline.  Retailers on board.

But the problem was that each successive month the forecast was revised downwards. Initially by small increments, then huge chunks fell out.

As often happens in these situations, the finance team were quietly recalculating their own version. And supply chain worked off a third version, because they didn’t trust either of the first two.

So, what’s the result when everyone has a different version of the truth?

Warehouses full of stock that nobody can sell.  Teams get sucked into fire-fighting instead of future-building.  And the whole organisation tiptoes around the problem which is a culture that subtly punishes honesty.

This isn’t a failing of forecasting, or process, or competence.  In this and many instances, the team are an intelligent, dedicated and well-intentioned group of people.

Instead, it’s a failure of leadership behaviour.  When people fear telling the truth, and especially truths that are unpalatable, unflattering, or politically inconvenient; the business becomes impossible to stabilise, let alone grow.

Why leaders must fix honesty first

The presenting symptoms of a lack of truthfulness always look operational: they can include stock issues, missed targets, unhappy customers, nervous boards.

But underneath, the root cause is always the same: People don’t feel safe being 100% honest.

Until a CEO, CMO or Sales Director fixes that fundamental, nothing else sticks. You have no hope of building up a brand or business if the foundation is made of sand and keeps moving.

Ray Dalio is famously intolerant of BS.  At Bridgewater Associates (a massive hedge fund company), he hard-wired what he called radical transparency into the culture — the idea that “meaningful work and meaningful relationships aren’t possible without radical truth.” People at Bridgewater can challenge anyone… and are encouraged to.

Bad news should travel just as fast as good news. While this is often painful, it is extremely productive.  And more you practice this behaviour, the more natural it becomes.

Another example is Indra Nooyi formally CEO of PepsiCo.  Known for her practice of “brutal clarity,” she created space for teams to speak truth to leadership without fear — which, Nooyi claims sharpened the company’s commercial discipline and produced growth year-after-year.

Business is about solving problems.  As you get bigger roles, you get bigger problems to solve.  Transparency is a pre-requisite because every effective leader knows you can’t fix what you can’t see.

 

Diversity of truth-telling: still absent

Organisations have made real progress on diversity and inclusion over the last decade. But I believe that one dimension still lags behind in a disappointing number of places: diversity of thinking.

In fact, in parallel with an increasingly tough marketing jobs market (and maybe nervousness about job security), I reckon it’s got worse.

I don’t mean HR-inspired screensavers that say “everyone matters”, or workshop charts proclaiming that “no idea is a bad idea”.  What really matters is how many people believe that it’s safe to say something the leader doesn’t want to hear.

Far too often, this kind of diversity is quietly discouraged.  Not intentionally — but through behaviour.

For example, a win is celebrated; whereas a risk is questioned.  A problem is minimised; but a “stretch assumption” quickly becomes baked into the base plan.

Slowly, a culture builds in which the truth only travels upwards if it’s been polished first.  There’s way too much narrative development, expectations management, and distraction from bad news.

Leaders can’t just announce an open door policy.  They must demonstrate they really want honesty.

So what practical steps can business leaders take to promote honest cultures?

Here are three simple high-impact ideas for leaders and their teams:

1. Reward truth, not optimism

When someone brings uncomfortable data, weak numbers, or early warning signs — thank them.  Reward the behaviour, not the story.  The fastest way to collapse honesty is to punish the person who speaks openly – they’re unlikely to be so candid a second time (and neither will anyone else who’s seen what happens).

2. Build a “single version of the truth” rhythm

Forecasts, numbers and assumptions should have one source, not three.  Run a cross-functional monthly (or even weekly) truth session where sales, finance, supply chain and marketing jointly agree what’s real.  The deeper the challenges, the more frequent.

Language can help.  For example, I spent 2 years rolling out Integrated Business Planning (S&OP) to 20 European markets.  One learning from that was using phrases like “most likely outcome” help to navigate a course between the extremes of optimism and pessimism.  Also, that it’s key to establish the security of a “bubble of truth” with teams – one in which reality is prized over fantasy, and candour over concealment.

3. Model what you want to receive

Leaders get the culture which their behaviours encourage.  If you skip over risk, so will everyone else.  If you admit uncertainty, others will too.  If you own your mistakes, honesty becomes normal rather than brave.

The quickest route to commercial stability isn’t better dashboards or cleverer planning tools.  It’s creating an environment where people can tell the truth without flinching.

One of the most powerful examples I’ve seen is when a general manager rewarded the marketing manager of a “failed” regional product test.

He separated the management (which was flawless) from the outcome (which was disappointing but still generated a bunch of valuable learnings that could be deployed in future activity).

What could have been an embarrassment, became a potent signal about what was valued by management.

The takeout

Clarity beats chaos.  And as a marketing or commercial boss, one of the most important aspects of culture you can nurture is that of radical transparency through your own behaviour.

Latest insights

Resource: Energy Inventory

Resource: Energy Inventory

Energy Inventory self-score questionnaire - a free-to-download resource. Click to open: ENERGY INVENTORY DEC26

Quotes about discernment

Quotes about discernment

"Avoid the superficial, penetrate the complex, go to the heart of the problem, and pinpoint the key factors” Bruce Lee   “A 'no' uttered from...

In a world of noise, complexity, and competing agendas, the leaders who win are those who cut through — simplifying smartly, then acting with clarity and conviction.

If that’s what you’re aiming for, let’s talk. No pitch, just a genuine conversation with someone who’s been in your shoes.