The assumptions you don’t see hurt you the most

I know it’s weird, but I get a kick out of getting stuck into tackling unsolvable issues with clients.  Sometimes, the most useful things you can bring are an external perspective and curiosity. 

Being objective and inquisitive can help unearth and name assumptions.  While assumptions can be a useful short cut to decision-making, they can also be a hidden barrier to progress.

To leaders charting a course for growth, the most dangerous assumptions are not the ones that we openly debate. They are the ones we don’t realise we are making.

Like fish in water, teams are surrounded by context, norms, and beliefs that feel so natural they become invisible. And what goes unchallenged quietly shapes decisions, priorities, and outcomes.

Why assumptions are so hard to spot

Experienced marketers are particularly vulnerable.

As you gain seniority, your judgement improves – but so does your confidence.  Over time, pattern recognition hardens into “what we know to be true.”  Your team stops questioning fundamentals and starts optimising within them.

This behaviour can be compounded by:

  • Cultural similarity – marketing teams are often educated, urban, digitally fluent, and socially liberal.  Bluntly, this means they (we) are not typical consumers
  • Echo chambers – conferences, LinkedIn, trade press, and peer networks reinforce prevailing views.  Marketers seek out novelty and “the next big thing”
  • Success bias – if something worked before, it becomes an implicit rule rather than a hypothesis.  It’s easy to forget about the influence of context, timing or even the role that luck played in historic outcomes.

None of this is done with malintent.  It’s only human.  But assumptions can create a risk that marketers confuse a shared belief with the external reality.

What goes wrong when assumptions go unchallenged

When assumptions remain invisible, several things can go wrong.

1. Strategy drifts away from the customer

Marketers begin designing for people like themselves (or for an imagined “rational” consumer) rather than how customers actually behave.  The result can be an elegant strategy, but one that doesn’t land.

2. Activity crowds out effectiveness

If you assume “more content,” “more channels,” or “more innovation” is always the answer, teams become busy without becoming better.   With this so-called busy work, effort and frustration increase but impact plateaus or weakens.

3. Signals are misread or ignored

Data that contradicts the prevailing narrative is explained away or discounted.  Weak performance may be blamed on competition or customers, not the underlying premise.  Confirmation bias is a real thing.  Contemplating that we might be wrong is uncomfortable (unless you practice it routinely).

The marketer’s real advantage

Great businesspeople are not the attention grabbers with the loudest voices or strongest opinions.  They’re the ones that ask the best questions.

In tough markets, better decisions happen if a leader or their team has the ability to:

  • Spot assumptions early
  • Challenge them calmly
  • Learn faster than competitors

As noted, this type of work can be uncomfortable.  It requires humility, curiosity, and restraint.  But it is also where clarity lives.

Assumptions you can see, can be managed.  And the ones that you surface early-on don’t get the chance to sink you later.

Latest insights

Resource: Energy Inventory

Resource: Energy Inventory

Energy Inventory self-score questionnaire - a free-to-download resource. Click to open: ENERGY INVENTORY DEC26

Quotes about discernment

Quotes about discernment

"Avoid the superficial, penetrate the complex, go to the heart of the problem, and pinpoint the key factors” Bruce Lee   “A 'no' uttered from...

In a world of noise, complexity, and competing agendas, the leaders who win are those who cut through — simplifying smartly, then acting with clarity and conviction.

If that’s what you’re aiming for, let’s talk. No pitch, just a genuine conversation with someone who’s been in your shoes.