Cases study: more clarity, less noise

I worked with a Director of a ~ £150m branded FMCG business that had just been acquired by a private equity firm.  Our work together is a practical example of separating signal from noise.

My client’s company had delivered several years of strong growth and was operating at about 15% EBITDA – roughly 50% better than the broader category norm. Indeed, I’m sure that the combination of momentum and impressive margins underpinned the new owner’s investment case.

Bit soon after completion, growth flattened. It wasn’t a total collapse, but there was a visible deceleration.

For the new owners, this immediately raised understandable questions. Performance seemed to undermine the investment case –  and embarrassingly early on.  Why was the growth weakening? Should more aggressive action be taken to drive buyer numbers? Were there faster routes to scale?  And perhaps privately, they were asking if the company’s management was good as they had thought?

Well-intentioned, but noisy

Ideas emerged quickly: heavier promotions, more NPD, accelerating NPD, broader distribution, more aggressive pricing. All had merits in isolation. But collectively they risked diluting the very economics (very healthy EBITDA) that had justified the acquisition.

The Marketing Director’s challenge was not competence — it was authority.

She needed to demonstrate that she understood the performance mechanics of the business more deeply than anyone else in the room, and that pursuing “more buyers at any cost” would probably compromise a margin structure that was a core part of the asset.

The underlying issue was misdiagnosis.

Historic growth had been driven by structural factors: disciplined distribution expansion, distinctive positioning and media support, pricing architecture, and supportive category and macro conditions. As those effects matured, the rate of growth just normalised at the new level. The business hadn’t deteriorated but stabilised at a new run rate.

Through a series of focused 1:1 sessions, we reframed the discussion around growing value. We clarified:

  • What genuinely drove historic growth and margin (and what steps were repeatable vs one off)
  • Which drivers were scalable without eroding EBITDA %
  • What level of growth was stretching, but economically coherent

The key was linking commercial ambition to financial reality. Penetration expansion was still possible — but not through indiscriminate activity. Distribution gains remained attractive, but we needed to be selective and go after those that reinforced pricing power not undermined it.

Once this logic was articulated clearly and backed with evidence, the dynamic shifted.

Back in control

The Marketing Director was no longer fielding reactive suggestions. She was leading a capital allocation conversation. The PE team could see that the 15% EBITDA margin wasn’t incidental; it was evidence of a well-balanced model. Protecting that while growing penetration required discipline, not haste.

Targets were recalibrated to reflect the actual growth engine of the brand. Investment was concentrated behind scalable drivers rather than dispersed across short-term stimulus. Crucially, the tension in the room reduced because expectations were now grounded in how the business truly worked.

Her reflection afterwards captured it neatly:

“Now the owners understand the real drivers of performance and we’re agreed on how to grow.  I’m not constantly fending off well-intentioned ideas.”

In this dynamic the risk was pursuing acceleration without understanding the economics of the engine.

When margin, penetration and distribution are treated as an integrated system not isolated levers, decisions improve and enterprise value can grow more reliably.

Often my role in these situations is straightforward: bring clarity to the growth mechanics, anchor ambition in financial logic, and ensure the investment case is supported rather than diluted.

This alignment helps protect both the brand and the owner’s investment.

 

 

 

Latest insights

Resource: Energy Inventory

Resource: Energy Inventory

Energy Inventory self-score questionnaire - a free-to-download resource. Click to open: ENERGY INVENTORY DEC26

Quotes about discernment

Quotes about discernment

"Avoid the superficial, penetrate the complex, go to the heart of the problem, and pinpoint the key factors” Bruce Lee   “A 'no' uttered from...

In a world of noise, complexity, and competing agendas, the leaders who win are those who cut through — simplifying smartly, then acting with clarity and conviction.

If that’s what you’re aiming for, let’s talk. No pitch, just a genuine conversation with someone who’s been in your shoes.