If – like me – you’re the product of an English state secondary school, talk of bike sheds may conjure up either fond memories or a nervous sweat – depending on your experiences.
However, this article is not about the fabled location of formative romantic encounters. Sorry about that.
In 1957, C. Northcote Parkinson described what he called the Law of Triviality.
His observation was disarmingly simple: committees give disproportionate attention to trivial issues because they are easier to understand.
In his example, a group approves plans for a nuclear power plant with minimal debate. Then they spend the next forty-five minutes arguing about the colour of the bike shed.
Everyone understands a bike shed (especially 20th century English adolescents). Fewer people understand a reactor.
This bias is how a population’s debt is allowed to grow to trillions, while its attention is directed onto minor (in the scheme of things) incentives for one or other electoral tribe.
If anything the dynamic of bikeshedding has intensified. In organisations, roles have become more specialized and matrix structures slice and dice (or often share) responsibilities between teams.
________________________________________
This matters more than we admit
Marketing is inherently exposed to bike shedding because much of its true leverage sits in areas that are ambiguous, long-term and difficult to quantify with much precision.
- Growth opportunity mapping
- Portfolio architecture
- Brand positioning
- Pricing and promotional strategy
- Distribution plans
These are commercially decisive questions, cognitively demanding, and politically loaded. Engaging properly with them requires judgement, experience, and a tolerance for uncertainty.
By contrast, debating the latest piece of creative, endless tweaks to internal emails, or interrogating small line items feels productive and measurable. It gives everyone something concrete to comment on.
Everyone who’s been to school has an opinion on education. Ergo sequitur, everyone that’s seen an advertisement has an opinion about marketing.
So we drift toward what is discussable, not necessarily what is decisive. This is a subtle but potentially but costly direction to travel.
________________________________________
Commercial consequence
In a business turning over £500m with a £5m marketing budget, the real upside probably doesn’t lie in squeezing incremental efficiency out of media buying or shaving costs from agency retainers (but nor should we allow spend to metastasize).
It’s in sharper choices about where to compete, which segments to prioritise, how to structure the portfolio, and whether pricing power is being strengthened or quietly diluted.
If senior attention clusters around minor tactical questions while structural issues attract only light scrutiny, you don’t just waste meeting time, you misallocate scarce leadership energy.
I’ve written many times about how leadership behaviour sets the tone much more effectively than the words spoken in town hall meetings or stuck along corridor walls. Over time, teams internalise the signal and learn that it is safer to optimise small things than to challenge big assumptions.
This is when strategy can become performative and execution amounts to “busy-ness”. Eventually sales, profit and share suffer, even through everyone looks industrious.
This is the core problem with triviality: it often presents as dynamic activity.
________________________________________
Useful approaches
Avoiding bike shedding requires conscious leadership.
Here are 3 simple principles you can apply:
- Anchor discussions to materiality. Ask which issues genuinely move revenue, margin or long-term brand equity. If the impact is marginal, limit the airtime.
- Separate understanding stuff from deciding stuff. Circulate performance or analytical detail in advance. Then use meeting time to debate implications and make decisions (not to collectively process information). If no-one reads circulated documents, do as King Amazon reportedly does and allow 30mins of quiet reading time at the start of exec meetings.
- Create a shared understanding of the signs – and the confidence to call-out when the group is heading down a rabbit hole. For example, a calm, gently delivered question like “Are we in bike shed territory?” can reset a room without offending people. Most people anyway. For a vocal few, being offended is a core identity.
________________________________________
Be more nuclear
Recognise the human tendency is to gravitate towards the bike shed, but stay quiet during the the nuclear reactor discussion.
It takes discipline to re-focus energy where it has most impact – not least because that’s normally where the tougher, messier and more ambiguous discussions are.
Let’s also recognise that it takes guts to be the one that asks apparently “simple” questions in a serious debate. However, from what I’ve seen, those that do so enjoy more credibility and respect from others.
Bike shed topics will always appear. The question is whether you quietly allow these to become the centre of gravity … or will you consciously steer energy to where it has most leverage?





