Don’t get drawn into the pantomime

Strategy is making choices.

And making choices is easier when you have a clear head and a sharp picture of the context.

Most of the news media is one big pantomime that invites the crowd to pick a side and act in the show.  When a headline says “Topic X: how worried should we be?” then you’re being handed a script.

The sheer abundance of content agitates people towards having an opinion on everything – even when they possess few or no facts.

This pressure to make quick judgements and take a position is something that’s hard to resist.

But taking a position too early – or based on authoritative-sounding gossip – is unhelpful.

Paradoxically, rather than accelerating action, forming quick opinions without much foundation slows things down.  This is because we spend time getting drawn into debating the rights & wrongs; polarisng personalities; or how something should be, rather than what it is.

Move from ‘who’s right?’ to ‘so what?’

But this subjective analysis stops us moving to the “so what” (dispassionate interpretation) and “what next” (action planning).

As the Stoics suggest, we must deal with the world as it is, not how we would wish it to be.

Almost everything you see or read carries some element of PR layered on top of the facts: optimism, self-interest, or a convenient narrative.  This isn’t necessarily malicious.  Sometimes it’s people protecting the recipient or putting something in the best light.  Sometimes the person doing the editing doesn’t even know they’re doing it.

This “curation” happens inside your own organisation, where people present things favourably, look for support on a pet project, or want to build momentum for an initiative.  It also happens externally – where media and tech platforms decide, via editors or algorithms, what to promote and, more importantly, what to leave out.

If someone on your team simply accepts what they’re told, without applying a moment of common sense and critical thought, they’re under-prepared.  This applies in both business and life.

A live example: energy and supply chains

Take the latest Middle East war as an example.

Truth is, as they say, the first casualty of war.  None of us properly understand what is going on.  But the long-term significance of events is almost certainly being underplayed by western media.

It is easy to get drawn into a debate about morals and military tactics – and I hear a lot of that going on.  But even with very incomplete information, as a commercial leader, it should be possible to move beyond gossip and draw conclusions about the “so what” and “what next.”

This is not being widely done.

Oil –  specifically diesel, kerosene and bunker fuel derivatives – is the bedrock of global logistics.  The war has not only closed shipping routes but destroyed refining and transportation infrastructure.  This cannot be quickly switched on again; it will take an extended time to rebuild.

The impact on your customers has been cushioned by drawing down strategic reserves and talking up the prospects of the conflict ending.

The point here is to argue for a dispassionate analysis – not to take sides or debate the morality of the situation.  A lot of people do intuitively know they’re being fed BS, and might roll their eyes, but they stop short of interrogating things and asking “so, what must I do now?”

The latest Middle East war will have direct implications for the choices facing senior commercial people and what their teams spend time doing.

If petrochemicals became 2–3× more expensive (which is plausible, but not a prediction), commercial teams could face a chain of decisions:

Costs: Raw materials, packaging and transport become more expensive

Pricing: Inflation leaves customers less able to absorb increases

Supply: Limited transport capacity forces choices about which products and customers to prioritise

Marketing: Budgets and media plans need to reflect those priorities

Products: New sources or materials may require reformulation, new packaging and fresh customer and stakeholder communications

But as someone smart once said, “necessity is the mother of invention,” so the situation will create incredible demand for innovation in things like process, product and partnerships.

Looking around the corner

The goal is not to bewilder the reader with endless “what ifs” – but simply to make the point that if we do not interrogate the information we receive, we cannot see things before they knock us or our teams off balance.

Over the years I have seen many people become frustrated (occasionally exhausted) when their jobs were consumed by the need to chase events which no one saw coming around the corner.

At least some of that frustration could have been avoided by people creating calm space to think; trusting their own common sense interpreting incoming information; then asking themselves “so, what should we do?”

In the next blog, I’ve pulled together five questions which may help you or your team to interrogate information before deciding how to act on it.

Latest insights

Resource: Energy Inventory

Resource: Energy Inventory

Energy Inventory self-score questionnaire - a free-to-download resource. Click to open: ENERGY INVENTORY DEC26

Quotes about discernment

Quotes about discernment

"Avoid the superficial, penetrate the complex, go to the heart of the problem, and pinpoint the key factors” Bruce Lee   “A 'no' uttered from...

In a world of noise, complexity, and competing agendas, the leaders who win are those who cut through — simplifying smartly, then acting with clarity and conviction.

If that’s what you’re aiming for, let’s talk. No pitch, just a genuine conversation with someone who’s been in your shoes.