Hunter & Gather: Strategy without execution is hallucination

Hunter & Gather (H&G) is an interesting, fast-growing brand that’s been on my radar for a while.

Founded in 2017 by Amy Moring & Jeff Webster, H&G is a food brand specializing in natural whole foods with a portfolio that includes sauces and dressings, various supplements and collagens, non-seed oils and animal fats.

The firm, which wants to expand into other markets including the US, had 2024 sales of about £12m, almost double that of its 2023 revenue.  What’s impressive is that historic growth was, according to its founders, funded from its own profits.

80% of Hunter & Gather sales are via its own D2C platform, although some of its products are now listed in Tesco under the retailer’s “accelerator programme”.

For reasons I shan’t bore you with, I’m now an H&G customer spending £30 a month or more on collagen peptides.  My mum has also joined the peptide party.

A sound strategy is important, but it’s what you do with it that ultimately puts money in the till.

And it’s difficult to be unimpressed – both as a marketer and a customer – with H&G’s pretty flawless marketing execution.

Here are five things I reckon they do well…

Sharp positioning & a story well-told

There’s a clear brand positioning and elements of the mix hang together coherently.  For example, product recipes take centre stage and clearly align with company values (promoting animal fats, not seed-oils; championing natural & simple versus ultra processed .. evidence-based nutrition that’s anti-inflammatory and rooted in ancestral foods).

Beyond the storytelling on the website, the founders are active on social media and judging by some of the LinkedIn spats, are happy to fight for their position on nutrition even when that’s at odds with fellow B-Corp members.

Too often brands attach themselves to a purpose that’s fashionable but irrelevant.  Whereas here there’s a substance and clarity of brand purpose that chimes with consumer interest in wellbeing and functional foods.

Masterful use of digital

Although there’s been some London-based outdoor advertising recently, almost all media activity is digital.  The brand is active on Instagram (both with organic & sponsored activity) claiming 70k+ followers and has an email subscribers list of 12k.

The brand succeeds in maintaining a coherent tone of voice and a consistent look & feel.  Digital channels enable H&G to elaborate on the brand story and provide tools and information on wellbeing to interested consumers.

However, without a meaningful physical retail presence or broadcast media, the brand will lack the mental availability of much larger incumbent brands.

Slick website and online shop experience

H&G’s website is easy to navigate and looks engaging.  There’s enough content to inform and sell, but not at the expense of a smooth user journey.

The online shop sits on Shopify, but some clever overlaid functionality ensures no opportunity is missed to cross-sell to a purchaser, encourage subscription purchases, etc.  Compared with supermarkets, H&G prices are premium and since there’s currently little margin-sharing, this functionality surely turbo charges customer value.

Operational efficiency

Order fulfilment is a smooth process – stuff turns up when it should, and communications are timely.  I highlight this because so many brands still disappoint when it comes to the ‘nuts and bolts’ of making and keeping promises.

Although it’s easy to overlook the importance of customer service, it’s a powerful touchpoint that either augments or undermines investment made in other marketing channels.

Emphasis on community to drive lifetime value

Once you have placed an order, this brand will not let you forget them.  Time will tell if the frequency is overwhelming.  But from CRM emails to in-delivery flyers, this brand is relentless at leveraging low-cost marketing touchpoints to educate and cross-sell.

The emphasis on “subscribe & save” and free shipping for certain order values (although increasingly common online tactics), coupled with seasonal promotions, suggests that H&G understands the spend potential of its (likely affluent) customer base.

Almost all food and beverage companies are looking to the wellness space for growth.  It’s a competitive market and the decision to play there is just the first tentative step on a journey to deliver a decent commercial return.

Despite its coherent brand positioning and charismatic founders, I have a suspicion that Hunter & Gather owes much to disciplined execution.   And that’s something marketing teams can learn from it.

Latest insights

Resource: Energy Inventory

Resource: Energy Inventory

Energy Inventory self-score questionnaire - a free-to-download resource. Click to open: ENERGY INVENTORY DEC26

Quotes about discernment

Quotes about discernment

"Avoid the superficial, penetrate the complex, go to the heart of the problem, and pinpoint the key factors” Bruce Lee   “A 'no' uttered from...

In a world of noise, complexity, and competing agendas, the leaders who win are those who cut through — simplifying smartly, then acting with clarity and conviction.

If that’s what you’re aiming for, let’s talk. No pitch, just a genuine conversation with someone who’s been in your shoes.