Practical tool: assumption surface model

One of the ways teams can waste energy is by arguing about solutions before they’ve agreed what has to be true for those solutions to work.

Before you debate what to do, slow the room down and spot the assumptions lurking underneath the surface…

Start with the beliefs, not the plan

Teams love to jump straight to action.  I bet you have heard statements like…

  • “We need a fresh new campaign.”
  • “We answer is a brand refresh.”
  • “We need a launch that’ll disrupt the market”
  • “We’ll hit our target ‘run rate’ by August”

When you hear this, consider asking a revealing question:

What has to be true for this to work?

The conversation will probably shift and you’ll start to hear statements like:

  • “New comms will cut-through better than our existing work”
  • “The category is stale; it just needs shaking up”
  • “Buyers are happy to pay more for additional benefits”
  • “With this strong NPD, we’ll get 80% distribution by Spring”

These are statements of belief … and these are where risks can quietly hide.

Separate statements of faith from facts

Once the assumptions/beliefs are visible, you can label them.

A simple three-way classification can work well:

  • Known – supported by evidence (e.g. up-to-date data)
  • Assumed – it’s plausible, but perhaps weakly evidenced
  • Unknown – we’re guessing (or hopeful) this is true

Most teams are surprised by how few sit in the first category.  But that discomfort is useful because it suggests where confidence is projected, but misplaced.

Pressure-test what matters most

Not all assumptions deserve equal attention.

Teams should focus on the ones that are high impact if they’re wrong; poorly evidenced; or pivotal to the success of the initiative.

In the classic 1969 film “The Italian Job”, Michael Cane’s character and his team are attempting a meticulously planned heist in Turin.  A critical step involves using explosives to blow open the doors of a secure building so they can proceed with the robbery.

However, they accidentally use far more explosive than intended.  Instead of neatly removing just the doors, the entire front of the building is blown apart.

Cane’s character reacts with exasperation and disbelief:  “You were only supposed to blow the bloody doors off!”

So… the moral of the anecdote is that to avoid unplanned outcomes, ask a few grounding questions:

  • What evidence would actually disprove this?
  • When did we last validate it – properly?
  • Who might disagree with us, and why?

The aim isn’t to eliminate assumptions. Instead, it is to be deliberate about which assumptions you’re willing to bet on and which ones need more work before you press “go”.

Putting effort into being clearer about assumptions shouldn’t slow your team down.  Instead, it’s about stopping them running confidently in the wrong direction.

To download a copy of the Assumption Surface model, click here (no signup required): Assumption Surface Model – Meaningful Few

Latest insights

Resource: Energy Inventory

Resource: Energy Inventory

Energy Inventory self-score questionnaire - a free-to-download resource. Click to open: ENERGY INVENTORY DEC26

Quotes about discernment

Quotes about discernment

"Avoid the superficial, penetrate the complex, go to the heart of the problem, and pinpoint the key factors” Bruce Lee   “A 'no' uttered from...

In a world of noise, complexity, and competing agendas, the leaders who win are those who cut through — simplifying smartly, then acting with clarity and conviction.

If that’s what you’re aiming for, let’s talk. No pitch, just a genuine conversation with someone who’s been in your shoes.