1. Strip the framing
“What would I believe if I’d never seen this presented this way?”
Remove the deck, the headlines and interpretation, the cool graphics, etc. What do the raw facts alone suggest?
2. Follow the interest
“Who benefits if I accept this at face value?”
Not cynicism, but a quick scan of whose agenda is served by you believing: the vendor, the analyst, the team pitching it, perhaps your own ego. Cui bono?
3. Separate knowledge from opinion
“What do I actually know (or have experienced), versus what I’ve been told?”
Distinguish your own pattern-recognition from borrowed opinion which someone has dressed up as insight.
4. Test your conviction
“If I had to bet my own money on this, would I?”
This question forces real belief rather than polite agreement or a comfortable consensus.
5. Find the plain answer
“What’s the simplest explanation I’m avoiding because it’s less interesting or less flattering?”
Spin usually adds drama or complexity, whereas common sense may point at a simpler, less exciting truth. Consider Occam’s razor.
Then: commit to a next step
“Given all this, what should we do differently?”
Identify a concrete action (or set of actions) you’re prepared to take, even with incomplete information. If unsure what to do, circle back to the thinking part.





